Tuesday, 3 November 2026

Day 104: Universal Evolutionism, Weston's Folly, and the Zeptoverse (3rd November)

 

The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: Lewis's critique of 'universal evolutionism' - the metaphysical prejudice that all of existence, from morality to mind, evolved from mindless chaos in order to keep God out of the picture.
• Source Material:  The Weight of Glory ("Is Theology Poetry?")

My Reflection

Today’s excerpt raises a highly controversial subject: Evolution. My personal view on this is based on a very simple observation, that being a refusal to accept that all of creation is born out of chaos, some form of cosmic accident. It calls to mind Weston’s (from Perelandra) belief in ‘emergent evolution’ - something which seems devised explicitly to keep God out of the picture.

In Perelandra, Weston and Ransom have a debate in which Weston abandons his earlier, purely mechanical and imperialistic view of science, and embraces a pantheistic philosophy he terms ‘Emergent Evolution’. He views the universe as driven by an inscrutable, blind, and inarticulate "Force" or "purposiveness" pushing upward toward higher complexity.

To Weston, "God" is not a real, personal Creator, but merely a metaphorical picture of the ‘future stage’ of evolution beckoning humanity forward. ‘The Devil’ is not a fallen spiritual entity, but simply a symbol for the ‘transcended past stage’ of evolution pushing from behind. For Weston, the supreme directive of existence is to serve the onward movement of this blind Force, regardless of the human cost.

Standing in direct opposition to Weston is Ransom, who upholds the classic understanding of creation. Ransom rejects the notion that a mindless, unconscious cosmic urge could ever generate life, mind, or moral purpose. Instead, he grounds reality in a personal, wise, and good God - known as Maleldil - who created the cosmos with intentional design.

When Weston boasts that the cosmic process aims at pure "spirituality," mind, and spontaneity - arguing that anything advancing "Spirit" is inherently justified - Ransom delivers a decisive rebuttal. He cuts through Weston's vague sentimentalism regarding the "spiritual" by pointing out a fundamental truth: spirituality itself is not automatically good. God is worshipped not merely because He is non-material or powerful, but because He is inherently wise and good. A spirit can be deeply evil, and an impersonal cosmic force stripped of moral character is not divine - it is dangerous.

The most chilling aspect of universal evolutionism lies in its moral consequences. Because Weston believes that "greatness always transcends mere moralism," he asserts that actions viewed as diabolical in one historical era naturally become the praised morality of the next.

When Ransom presses Weston on the practical implications of his philosophy - asking directly whether obedience to this blind "Life-Force" would justify murder, treason, or publishing scientific lies - Weston does not flinch. He flatly answers, "Yes." In Weston's view, individual human beings have no permanent value; they are merely temporary, disposable receptacles for the cosmic current. Traditional morality, justice, and truth are dismissed as outworn concepts that must be shattered whenever the evolutionary urge demands progress.

Ransom urgently warns Weston of the catastrophic danger inherent in his philosophy. To surrender oneself unconditionally to an ambiguous, mindless "Force" is an act of supreme recklessness, noting that "a thing might be a spirit and not good for you."

The debate in Perelandra highlights the deep hazard of modern naturalism's favourite myth. When we conflate biological mechanics with an all-encompassing "universal evolutionism," we do not merely adopt an unplausible explanation for how mind and cosmos came to be - we undermine the very foundations of human dignity, moral truth, and rational thought.

As Ransom's defence demonstrates, true reality is not an accidental upward climb out of mindless chaos, nor is it a blind current to which we must sacrifice our conscience. It is the intentional work of a personal, good Creator. Recognising the limits of universal evolutionism allows us to step out of a perilous metaphysical prejudice and anchor our lives once more in objective truth, genuine goodness, and the sacred value of the individual person.

Today in the news is a new scientific idea relating to the origin of the Universe called the ‘Zeptoverse’. Weston would be in his element, as science seems hell-bent on any form of research which will take God out of the picture, reducing humans to nothing more than a cosmic accident. I was always struck by the passage in the book where Lewis writes:

"It is the idea that humanity, having now sufficiently corrupted the planet where it arose, must at all costs contrive to seed itself over a larger area: that the vast astronomical distances which are God's quarantine regulations, must somehow be overcome."

I may be an object of ridicule to some, but I cannot believe the human experience is nothing more than the result of billions of years where a primordial soup eventually produced Shakespeare and Mozart.

Why This Matters

Elevating a biological theory into a universal philosophy robs humanity of its inherent dignity. Acknowledging an intentional Creator ensures that human life, morality, and art retain their sacred, objective value, rather than being dismissed as temporary evolutionary by-products.

My Action for Today

Today, I will appreciate a piece of profound human creation - perhaps listening to Mozart or reading Shakespeare - as glorious evidence of intentional, divine design rather than a cosmic accident.

Reader Question

Do you find it difficult to reconcile modern scientific theories about the origins of the universe with the idea of a personal, intentional Creator?

No comments:

Post a Comment