The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: Lewis's argument that "emergent evolution" is an optical illusion, reminding us that complex things always originate from something equally or more complex.• Source Material: The Weight of Glory ("Is Theology Poetry?")
My Reflection
Today’s excerpt opens with Lewis using the metaphor of the owl and the egg. It surprised me, as I had only ever known it as the chicken or the egg. Funnily enough, when I looked this up on the Internet, the Google AI response was, "the egg came first." So, I started my reading somewhat confused.
Lewis goes on to reiterate this idea using the images of an acorn and the oak, the embryo and the adult human, and modern rockets and a rudimentary engine. All these examples illustrate the same conundrum regarding evolution. However, in the last example of the rocket, Lewis states that even though one engine relied on a previous iteration, both of these rockets ultimately relied on what he calls "a man of genius." He is referencing 'emergent evolution', a concept he explores deeply through his character of Weston in Perelandra.
Emergent evolution is the philosophical and scientific hypothesis that entirely new properties, qualities, or levels of organisation (such as life, consciousness, or mind) appear at critical turning points during evolution. These new traits arise from the interactions and rearrangements of simpler, pre-existing parts, yet they cannot be predicted or fully explained by studying those parts in isolation. It is the idea that one plus one can equal three - an idea that goes against the basic logic that it should equal two.
Even though Lewis writes in a way that can sometimes feel obfuscated to me, he still shows that this concept makes no sense. Lewis calls it a "pure hallucination," a term popular today when discussing the output of AI responses - something I can certainly testify to experiencing based on my own use of said technology. Modern science seems fixated on the idea of eradicating the Creator from our world and reinforcing the notion that all life is born out of chaos and is nothing more than happenstance. By contrast, proponents of intelligent design and creationism point to the human eye as an example of irreducible complexity and functional engineering, arguing that its parts are far too interdependent to have formed by unguided evolutionary processes.
To me, both sides of this argument seem to carry weight, and I am left asking the question: "Cannot both be true?" Could it not be that God created this universe in which evolution was allowed to happen? Did God not tip over the first of the evolutionary dominoes?
When I look at the world and all its complexities, not only those found on Earth but in the wider universe, it strikes me that it cannot simply be by accident. I am also struck by the fact that humans seem to be alone in the universe. Some often argue that there must be other intelligent life, but we simply have not found it yet. In the film adaptation I am making of Lewis’s book Perelandra, I made the decision to include the following quote by Arthur C. Clarke:
"Two possibilities exist: either we are alone in the Universe...or we are not...Both are equally terrifying."
I feel this is an idea truly worthy of debate and consideration.
Historical Note: 1914 - Warren Lewis is sent to France with the 4th Company 7th Divisional Train, British Expeditionary Force.
Why This Matters
When we observe the universe, viewing it strictly through the lens of random chaos strips it of its profound mystery. Acknowledging that a divine Creator may have tipped the first evolutionary domino allows us to marvel at both the mechanics of science and the poetry of intelligent design.
My Action for Today
Today, I will take a moment to look at something incredibly complex in the natural world - perhaps simply my own eye in the mirror - and appreciate it not as a random accident, but as a masterpiece of intentional design.
Reader Question
Do you believe that evolution and intelligent design must be mutually exclusive, or could God have simply tipped the first evolutionary domino?

No comments:
Post a Comment