The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: Accepting the limits of our understanding, abandoning unanswerable questions, and focusing on the path ahead.• Source Material: Mere Christianity (Preface)
My Reflection
Today’s excerpt is incredibly short, yet it poses a deeply profound question. Lewis admits that there are simply questions at issue between Christians to which we have not been told the answer, and perhaps never will be.
To me, the greatest revelation of getting older is realising that the more we learn, the less we know. Answers almost inevitably lead to more and more questions. Reading Lewis' blunt conclusion - that if we demand answers to these great mysteries, the Divine response is essentially, "What is that to thee? Follow thou Me" - immediately brought another great writer to mind.
Like Lewis, E.M. Forster has been a lifelong passion of mine. I was sharply reminded of a passage in his novel A Room with a View, where Mr. Emerson speaks affectionately, but with great concern, about his son, George. He explains that George is melancholic, constantly questioning the meaning of the universe, and he implores Lucy to help pull him out of his brooding state. He says: "Make him realise that by the side of the everlasting Why there is a Yes - a transitory Yes if you like, but a Yes."
My absolute favourite of Forster's works is Howards End, and looking at it through this lens, Leonard Bast's entire character arc is a tragic embodiment of the very struggle Mr. Emerson describes. Where Mr. Emerson fears his son George will succumb to the melancholy "Why" of existence, Bast is a man desperately trying to claw his way towards the "Yes" of life - which he equates with culture, beauty, and poetry - in order to escape the crushing, mundane reality of his poverty.
This ties perfectly into my frustrations over the last few days with Lewis's dense theology. We can easily become trapped in the "everlasting Why" of theological caucus races, demanding to understand the exact mechanics of salvation. But Lewis’ instruction today is the perfect antidote. We do not need to solve the mysteries of the universe. We simply need to look at the life immediately in front of us, find that transitory "Yes", and quietly get on with living it.
Why This Matters
There are questions about life, faith, and human existence to which we will never obtain meaningful answers. Refusing to let the unanswerable "Why" paralyse us allows us to engage with the beauty, duty, and practical faith of the "Yes."
My Action for Today
Today, I will step away from the "everlasting Why." If I find my head spinning with unanswerable questions, I will consciously redirect my energy towards a practical, immediate "Yes" in my everyday life.
Reader Question
Do you ever find yourself paralysed by the "everlasting Why" of life's big questions, or are you generally able to ground yourself in the "transitory Yes"?
Life is full of dilemmas that make us question everything we do, say, think and deliberate which can be paralysing in itself. Learning to step back and ground oneself is an art that once mastered is peace
ReplyDeleteThis is absolutely been my own journey over the last 12 months. To simply stop trying to find the answers; to find the WHY for everything. This pursuit really does take away from us all living and being present in our human lives. And we ARE here to actually LIVE - to experience joy, love, grief, anger, fear and everything else in between. The time to BE is NOW. It always has been. Wonderful piece ❤️
ReplyDelete