The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: The concentric circles of the human mind, the danger of keeping virtues in the realm of imagination, and Screwtape's inverted logic..• Source Material: The Screwtape Letters ("Fantasy Virtues")
My Reflection
Today’s excerpt takes us back to the inverted logic of The Screwtape Letters, a book which - if you have read my previous posts on the subject - you will know I often struggle to navigate. Today, Screwtape talks about ‘shoving’ real virtues outward into the realm of fantasy, while pushing desirable, destructive qualities inward into the Will. The goal is to completely swap a person's desires, replacing what is actually good and achievable with unrealistic ideals that ultimately do more harm than good.
I readily admit that I have, from time to time, found myself completely turned around by this, my head filled with goals which are entirely unrealistic. In fact, worrying that I had set myself on a ‘fool’s errand’ was my original fear when I started this daily blog.
Lewis illustrates perfectly how one can become diverted from true intentions. For example, I once had this grand notion that I could play the cello. I spent large sums of money on the instrument itself and on lessons, but after two years I had made no significant progress, and now it sits in the corner of my room gathering dust. It serves as a continual, mocking reminder of failure - a quixotic action that leads me to view myself as someone incapable of anything remotely creative.
Was I just lacking ability and talent, or was this Screwtape fooling me into focusing on an unrealistic, unachievable dream?
Looking closely at Lewis' circles, I suspect it is the latter - and the real demonic trick is not the cello itself, but the lingering lie it left behind. That dusty instrument is trying to convince you that you lack creativity, which is frankly absurd.
The cello was a fantasy virtue - a romantic idea of what creativity should look like. By keeping your focus on the failed fantasy, the 'Enemy' distracts you from the very real, tangible creative work you are successfully doing every single day in the centre of your Will.
Historical Footnote (28th September)
1931: Lewis returns to a belief "that Jesus Christ is the Son of God" while riding to Whipsnade Zoo in the sidecar of his brother Warren's motorcycle. (A perfect example of a profound, life-changing shift happening in the most ordinary, active moment!)
Why This Matters
We often punish ourselves for failing at grand, romanticised hobbies, allowing those failures to blind us to our actual talents. True virtues and genuine creativity belong in the realm of daily action and habit (the Will), not in the realm of unattainable fantasy.
My Action for Today
Today, I will look at that dusty cello not as a monument to failure, but as a reminder to stay grounded. I will ignore the fantasy of what I thought I should be doing, and focus my energy on the creative tools and projects I actually enjoy using.
Reader Question
Have you ever abandoned a romanticised hobby, only to realise later that your true talents simply lay in a completely different direction?
No comments:
Post a Comment