Monday, 2 November 2026

Day 103: Proust, Piano Lessons, and the Achilles Heel of Screwtape (2nd November)

 

The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: The demonic strategy of replacing a person's genuine, simple pleasures with fashionable, socially "important" distractions.
• Source Material:  The Screwtape Letters ("Raw Material")

My Reflection

About thirty years ago, I was taking piano lessons and my teacher asked me if I had ever read The Screwtape Letters. I knew of C.S. Lewis, as I had read The Chronicles of Narnia as a child, but I had never heard of Screwtape. She lent me a copy of the book, and I think this was the very beginning of my struggle - a struggle which continues to this very day.

I passed my English Literature 'O'-Level at the end of the 1970s, and this was the start of my love of literature. I have always had a preference for what people call 'the classics' and never balked at the prospect of reading dense texts, rarely ever struggling with the content. I have even managed to read Proust’s À la recherche du temps perdu (In Search of Lost Time), which is one of the goliaths of literature. All this being said, The Screwtape Letters completely defeats me.

Imagine my deep disappointment when, yet again, today’s passage is another excerpt from this book. I have read and re-read this excerpt and feel I can only glean the most minimal of meaning from it. It seems that Screwtape is encouraging his minion to try and distract his 'patient' from his love of simple and meaningful activities in favour of less fulfilling ones, or ones which offer no enrichment.

Some part of me suspects that one of Screwtape’s minions is at work as I am writing these blog posts and is actively attempting to derail my project. Part of me is tempted to flick through the rest of the book just to see how many more of these excerpts are from this challenging work. I am beginning to develop a deep hatred of this book as it serves as a point of failure, which is something I do not cope with easily.

What is it about this particular work of Lewis which is proving to be something of an Achilles heel? Perhaps it is the exhausting inverted logic, or perhaps it is exactly what the passage describes: a deliberate attempt to strip the simple pleasure out of my daily reading.

Why This Matters

When a text relies on reversed logic and demonic perspectives, it can create a profound sense of cognitive exhaustion. Recognising that frustration is sometimes the intended effect of the satire helps remove the burden of feeling like a failure.

My Action for Today

Today, I will take Screwtape's fear to heart. I will deliberately engage in a simple, personal pleasure that I genuinely like - completely ignoring whether it is 'important' or not - and I will refuse to let this book steal my joy.

Reader Question

Have you ever encountered a deeply celebrated book that simply defeated you, serving as your own literary Achilles heel?

No comments:

Post a Comment