The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: Lewis's view that life is not a film we alter through prayer, but a reality where our prayers and the free will of others were already woven into the script.• Source Material: Miracles ("Not a Film Unrolling")
My Reflection
In today’s passage, Lewis offers more thoughts on the nature of prayer and our assumptions about its effectiveness. He argues that rather than prayer being a way of actively changing outcomes on the fly, our prayers have already been considered in eternity and either acknowledged or refused. I find it strange that Lewis would state prayers could be refused for the "ultimate good," but he asks us to consider the free will of the "wicked." If I am reading the passage correctly, he suggests that because we experience free will, we cannot always be protected from cruelty, lest God turn the human race into mere automata.
I know I am on shaky ground here, as after reading the passage several times, I am still unable to fully grasp the absolute "truth" of his thoughts. However, this is something that over the past ninety-nine days I have come to accept. I am not always going to grasp his ideas immediately, and I need to contemplate them over time in the hope that some revelation will eventually occur. I used to view this as some kind of failure on my part, but now I am much more inclined to simply accept that today the door did not open, and hope that tomorrow it will.
After reading the last few passages, I have begun to form the uneasy opinion that we seem to be trapped in an existence in which we are powerless to change the outcomes of our lives. If, as Lewis illustrates, our lives are not a film unravelling in which we can use prayer to actively alter the plot, then we are simply a passive audience sitting in the theatre of our own life, watching a film that is already scripted and produced. Will there be a surprise ending? Will the villain be revealed? Will the guy get his girl? It seems all we can do is grab our popcorn and see how our lives play out on the screen.
And yet, a part of me deeply rebels against this passivity. It brings to mind a song I treasure deeply - Gold Dust by the singer-songwriter Tori Amos. In it, she offers a starkly different, profoundly human thought about our existence:
"We make it up as we go along."
Perhaps that is the true tension of free will. Lewis may argue the script is already printed in eternity, but down here in the theatre, it certainly feels like we are frantically making it up scene by scene.
And just to add a touch of synchronicity to all this heavy theological pondering, as I was writing these exact words about the cosmic mechanics of prayer, my Spotify playlist on random shuffle chose to play a favourite track of mine. Its title? Prayer by GoGo Penguin. It is a spooky little coincidence that makes me wonder if that algorithmic choice was scripted "before all worlds", or if the universe is simply throwing me a comforting wink while making it up as it goes along.
Why This Matters
Releasing the need to fully comprehend the mechanical workings of the universe removes a tremendous burden. When we accept that some theological doors will not open immediately, we free ourselves to simply experience the beautiful, unscripted messiness of making life up as we go.
My Action for Today
Today, I will not force myself to untangle the unanswerable questions of determinism. I will simply sit back, grab my metaphorical popcorn, and appreciate the freedom of making up today's scenes as I go along.
Reader Question
Do you ever feel like a passive audience member watching the predetermined film of your life, or do you believe we are truly just making it up as we go along?

No comments:
Post a Comment