Friday, 30 October 2026

Day 100: Paradisal Man, Moments of Pleasure, and a Centenary Milestone (30th October)

 

The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: The perfect alignment of duty and desire before the Fall, and how modern man is swept away by pleasure rather than directing it to God.
• Source Material:  The Problem of Pain ("Our Keenest Pleasure")


My Reflection

In today’s passage, Lewis discusses how, before 'the Fall', our desire to serve God was perfectly aligned with His will so that there was no question of conflict. For us, living in a broken world, what we want to do and what we ought to do are usually in direct conflict. For Pre-Fall Man, those two things were completely identical.

I think I often feel a pang of guilt if I enjoy doing a good deed, wondering if I am doing it for God or just to make myself feel nice. Lewis says that dilemma did not exist in Eden.

In Perelandra, the Green Lady (also known as Tinidril) debates with the Un-man as he attempts to suggest that Maleldil might secretly desire her disobedience to prove her independence. She appeals directly to her unfallen desires. She never questions whether she is doing something just because she "happens to like it," because her entire will is perfectly, joyfully, and effortlessly aligned with Maleldil's:

"How can we not obey what we love?"

"How can I step out of His will save into something that cannot be wished? Shall I start trying not to love Him or the King - or the beasts? It would be like trying to walk on water or swim through islands... To walk out of His will is to walk into nowhere."

Lewis uses a metaphor comparing a horse to a swift stream. When an unfallen person felt happiness, their desire for God rode that happiness like a well-managed horse. They remained in complete control and deliberately steered their joy directly toward the Divine. For us, however, when we experience intense happiness or pleasure, it acts like a rushing river. We get completely swept away by the feeling, lose control, and forget about God entirely, drowning in the pleasure itself.

All of this leaves me with a feeling that our pleasures are yet again transactional and subject to examination. How can I enjoy anything if I have to continually assess my motivations to ensure they meet these exacting standards?

It brings to mind a song by Kate Bush called Moments of Pleasure. While Lewis speaks of the pristine joy of Eden, she captures the dual nature of life in our broken world, reflecting on the idea that:

"...just being alive it can really hurt."

She balances the deep sorrow of missing those who have passed away with profound gratitude for the precious times shared with them. At the climax of the song, Bush softly calls out the names of her departed friends and loved ones in a deeply moving roll call that transforms private grief into a universal human experience. It is a beautiful reminder that our earthly pleasures, though imperfect and tinged with sorrow, are still immensely valuable. When I experience joy, I often - if not always - mentally thank the Divine for the 'fruit' I have been given, often being surprised that it is better than I expected.

As an example, today marks my one-hundredth post, and I take immense pleasure in the fact that I have been sufficiently disciplined to create the space to read Lewis and to think about my relationship with God. If all of this was written 'before all worlds', then surely my efforts are aligned with the will of the Creator. I must admit to being confused by Lewis's complex language, but this is nothing new. If I am found wanting, all I can say is I have tried my best. I am truly enjoying the journey of reading, digesting, and writing my thoughts on the topics Lewis discusses.

Am I riding a controlled horse, or simply drowning in the pleasure itself?

Why This Matters

Continually interrogating our joy for pure motives can rob us of the simple grace of the present moment. Reaching a milestone like one hundred days of disciplined reflection - and cherishing the bittersweet memories of those we love - is a beautiful offering in itself, regardless of theological perfection.

My Action for Today

Today, I will celebrate reaching my one-hundredth post without second-guessing my motivations, simply enjoying the hard-earned fruit of this creative discipline and the precious moments of pleasure it brings.

Reader Question

Do you ever feel guilty for taking pleasure in a good deed, or do you simply accept the joy as a bittersweet gift of being alive?

No comments:

Post a Comment