The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: Surrender, creaturely obedience as an intrinsic good, and treading Adam’s dance backward.• Source Material: The Problem of Pain ("Surrender in Obedience")
My Reflection
Today’s passage may as well be written in Greek; I don’t speak Greek. All I can see when I read the excerpt are the words ‘surrender’ and ‘obedience’—they are right there in the title. I thought I was progressing in my ability to decode Lewis, to understand his ideas, but today sees a small hand rise from the theological trenches tightly gripping a small white flag. If I were not completely committed to spending a full year on this project, today’s passage could possibly have ended the journey. I defy most people to read today’s excerpt and say, “Oh yes, I see what you mean, Jack.”
So, instead, I want to illustrate an example where C.S. Lewis writes and postulates something in such a way that it feels like a genuine, breath-taking philosophical meditation.
In Perelandra, the Green Lady is responding to a subtle temptation by Weston (the Un-man), who suggests that if she makes herself wiser than her husband (the King), the King will “love her more”. Specifically, Weston asks her:
"Do you not think the King must sometimes be tired of being the older? Would he not love you more if you were wiser than he?"
And this is the line which has rented space in my head from the instant I read it; the Green Lady replies:
"How could anyone love anything more? It is like saying a thing could be bigger than itself."
The Green Lady finds this premise completely meaningless because her experience of love is already unreserved and whole; for her, love is an absolute, not a measure—it simply is. Claiming to love something "more" is a logical and mathematical impossibility, like saying an object could be physically larger than itself.
This is when I marvel at Lewis's surgeon-like precision: cutting straight through our fallen assumptions to produce a concept truly greater than the sum of its parts. In that single response from the Green Lady, love isn't a sliding scale or a transaction—it is an absolute. He defines love not as a dial you turn up or down, but as a pure binary: it either exists in its entirety, or it does not.
In The Problem of Pain, Lewis is describing a love that feels strictly conditional and transactional. His argument insists that to participate in the good, you must 'freely surrender' and offer up 'mere obeying' to reverse the Fall. It sets up an economy: God demands, you submit, and only then is the relationship properly aligned. It implies that God's favour and communion are contingent upon you treading Adam's dance backward. That naturally feels like a system where you are forever earning your keep, proving yourself worthy, or apologising for simply existing.
In contrast, the Green Lady in Perelandra exposes why that theological framework feels so hollow. In Perelandra, love isn't conditional, nor is it an economy of leverage, merit, or performance; it is an absolute binary: it either is, or it isn't.
In that unfallen world, love doesn't increase because someone behaved better, grew wiser, or grovelled more effectively. It simply exists, whole and complete, mirroring the very premise I grew up with: that God does not merely possess love as a tool of reward or punishment, but that God is Love as His fundamental, default reality.
I don't think I am inventing a contradiction out of thin air. To me, it seems like Lewis is disagreeing with himself. His mythic imagination grasped divine love far better than his rigid academic logic ever could.
Am I wrong in wanting a relationship free of constant bargaining, collars, and tests of obedience?
Sorry, Jack, but today you totally lost me in The Problem of Pain. And to anyone reading this who hasn’t read Perelandra, I can only say… read it!
Why This Matters
When theological discourse reduces our relationship with the Creator to legalistic mechanics of "mere obeying" and unconditional surrender, it quickly becomes dry, alienating, and cold. Turning to myth and storytelling reminds us that true divine connection is rooted in an unreserved, whole love that defies petty human leverage and transactional obedience.
My Action for Today
Today, I will not force myself to untangle dense, inaccessible academic theology. Instead, I will rest in the Green Lady's profound insight—that genuine love is already whole, complete, and cannot be bartered for with clever rules.
Reader Question
Do you struggle more with legalistic definitions of obedience, or do you find clarity when spiritual ideas are explored through story and myth?

No comments:
Post a Comment