Sunday, 11 October 2026

Day 81: Tender Words, Heavy Yokes, and the Troubling of Decent Lives (11th October)

 


The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: Why misfortune falls upon decent people, Lewis's appeal to St Augustine, and the claim that God deliberately troubles modest happiness to reveal our insufficiency.
• Source Material:  The Problem of Pain ("Tender Words")

My Reflection

I find the title of today’s passage very antiphrastic (Lewis is not the only person capable of using words which the majority of people have rarely heard of); possibly the title was chosen by the editor of the book, Patricia S. Klein, or possibly Lewis himself.

Lewis seems to recognise that he is on somewhat shaky ground, as he couches his argument with terms like ‘tenderness’, ‘hostile reader’, and makes himself ‘personally responsible’, citing the example of St Augustine. The latter’s name evokes the theory of Original Sin, the absolute need for baptism, the punishment of unborn babies, his denial of the state of Limbo, and the subsequent (what I see as an about-face) inclusion of it by St Thomas Aquinas. I never really understand how theologians can change or modify scripture either to suit their own personal beliefs or in response to the reactions of the laity, but I feel I am being drawn away from the passage into wider arguments.

Today’s passage should in fact be titled: No Good Deed Goes Unpunished.

I am still deeply conflicted around the notion that human beings require a divine ‘wake-up’ call in order to acquire a love of God. I feel as if the Creator strokes our head with one hand whilst slapping our face with the other. We are set an impossible task by Lewis when he argues that our modest prosperity, our simple lives, our families and loved ones, and any good works we may perform are not sufficient to make us blessed. What is it that God actually wants from us? A life of servitude?

I am reminded of a passage from the Bible (Matthew 11:28–30) where Jesus asks His followers to take up His yoke, for it is light. When I read this, despite what I have read later or had explained to me, the symbol of the yoke does not feel like a ‘partnership in labour’. The very definition of a yoke is a wooden collar or harness placed on an animal to pull a heavy load. Despite how light this burden is described, it still does not equate to a loving relationship: someone is in control, and it is certainly not the animal wearing the collar.

I think what saddens me the most is that my writings present me as one at war with the Divine, and this is most certainly not the case. I truly want a loving and nurturing relationship, but why must it be so coercive? Why must it be filled with seemingly unobtainable rules and regulations? Why must unbaptised babies suffer, to quote St Augustine, "[the]...mildest and lightest condemnation of all...", consisting primarily of the lack of the beatific vision (separation from God) rather than active torment? Why is this even a conversation we should be having?

I was taught at a very early age that God is love. In my sixties, I am not so sure anymore.

Historical Footnote (1930)

  • 1930: Lewis, his brother Warren, Mrs Janie Moore, her daughter Maureen, and Mr Papworth the dog move into their new home, The Kilns, near Oxford. This will be Lewis's home until his death.

Why This Matters

Questioning the coercive framing of suffering does not signify hostility towards God; it signals a longing for genuine love over forced servitude. Honest spiritual exhaustion carries far more integrity than pretending that divine harm feels like tenderness.

My Action for Today

Today, I will cherish my simple, modest joys and the love in my life without feeling guilty that they are "insufficient". I will allow myself to mourn the childhood certainty that "God is love" without pretending to have tidy answers.

Reader Question

How do you reconcile a God who is defined as "love" with theological arguments that He deliberately ruins our peace to gain our attention?

No comments:

Post a Comment