Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Day 112: The Paradox of Pacifism and the Reality of War (11th November)

 


The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: A stark warning that state pacifism is self-defeating, as a society that refuses to fight will inevitably be conquered by totalitarian regimes.
• Source Material:  The Weight of Glory (Why I Am Not a Pacifist)

My Reflection

I was hoping that the passage chosen for today, the 11th of November, would reference Lewis’s own time of service in the trenches of the First World War. Instead, it continues his writings on the subject of pacifism. At first glance, I found myself slightly confused by the text. Is Lewis advocating for pacifism here? Reading closer, my initial suspicion was confirmed: he is arguing that pure pacifism is ultimately self-defeating.

Lewis makes the sobering point that if a free, liberal society adopts complete pacifism, it makes itself entirely vulnerable to totalitarian neighbours who haven't. By laying down their arms, the pacifist society simply hands the keys over to a dictator who will immediately wipe out the pacifists. As Lewis bluntly states, "Pacifism of this kind is taking the straight road to a world in which there will be no Pacifists."

It is a deeply saddening reality that while pacifism is a lofty, beautiful, and admirable concept, it is entirely unworkable in human society. In my youth, I genuinely felt that pacifism was the only solution to humanity's problems. However, now in my sixties, life has taught me that these idealistic principles remain unobtainable in the context of the deeply flawed, tribal world we actually live in. Sometimes, force is tragically necessary to protect the vulnerable from those who would do them harm. It brings to mind the famous, melancholic tagline from the video game Fallout: "War never changes."

Historical Note: On this day in 1918, the Armistice was signed, marking the end of World War I.

Why This Matters

It is vital to distinguish between a personal desire for peace and the political reality of defending a society. On Armistice Day, as we remember the devastating cost of war, Lewis reminds us that refusing to stand against tyranny does not bring peace; it only empowers those who thrive on violence.

My Action for Today

Today, as I observe the silence for Armistice Day, I will reflect not just on the tragedy of war, but on the hard, necessary courage of those who fought to ensure we still live in a society free enough to debate these ideas.

Reader Question

How have your own idealistic principles from your youth changed as you have grown older and experienced more of the real world? Let me know in the comments.

No comments:

Post a Comment