The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: The distinction between hitting back out of egoistic revenge, which is forbidden, and using force to protect the innocent or uphold a duty, which is sometimes necessary.• Source Material: The Weight of Glory ("Why I Am Not a Pacifist")
My Reflection
Today is a challenging day as it is Remembrance Sunday here in the UK. Having watched the coverage on the BBC and observed the two-minute silence, I sat down to write today’s post. Whilst waiting for the kettle to boil, I looked out of the window to see the myriad of ruby leaves from the Japanese acer falling to the ground. As they gather in the garden, I am reminded of how each one seems to represent a life lost in the numerous, seemingly senseless conflicts in the history of our world.
Today’s excerpt itself continues to explore how we rationalise the act of defending others against the act of taking another’s life. The way Lewis explains this paradox is clear and insightful, leaving me with the eternal dilemma of when is force justified? Lewis seems to make this absolutely clear: force is not justified when borne out of sheer anger, but it is necessary when another’s life is at stake. However, this seems to be couched in one’s perspective of who is the aggressor and who one is protecting. As Lewis notes, the duties of a soldier defending the public against an enemy are driven by motives entirely different from egoistic retaliation.
Yet, these moral questions are never easy, and the cost of this "justified force" is exactly what we are mourning today.
I have a relative called William Shirley, who died at just 21 in the Boer War in 1900. He died in South Africa and his body was never recovered.
This lack of a physical resting place brings to mind a slight detour, yet a deeply poignant literary connection. I am a great fan of Simon Brett's books, and in his light-hearted mystery novel Murder in the Museum, there is a fictional poem titled "Threnody for the Lost." It is presented as a heart-breaking tribute to a soldier presumed killed in Flanders, focusing specifically on the acute, unresolved pain of bereavement when there is no tangible body to mourn. While the book itself belongs to a lighter genre, this poetic device is unexpectedly moving. It perfectly articulates the specific grief of having no physical grave to visit - a silent sorrow my great-grandmother must have carried for William.
From these quiet, unburied griefs of the Boer War and Flanders, Remembrance Sunday always brings a wider flood of fragmented history to my mind. I think of the famous football match in No Man's Land on Christmas Day in 1914, a fleeting moment of humanity amidst the slaughter. I think of the film Oh! What a Lovely War (R.I.P. Dame Maggie Smith), which so brilliantly captured the dissonance between the jolly, patriotic songs and the meat grinder of the trenches.
I am reminded of the old trench superstition that taking a "third light" from a single match is unlucky - a stark reminder of snipers in the dark. It originated in the Boer War and was solidified in the trenches of WWI. The belief was that striking a match alerted a sniper to your presence; the second light gave him time to aim; and the soldier who took the third light was shot.
It is remarkable how many of the old wartime songs still remain in my mind - classics such as Wish Me Luck As You Wave Me Goodbye, Roll Out the Barrel, and my personal favourite, Keep the Home Fires Burning. I wonder if being brought up by my maternal grandparents for much of my early childhood influenced these recollections and possibly my character, which seems to grow stronger as the years pass, but I digress.
Today I was very happy to see a purple poppy wreath on the BBC broadcast. It is there to acknowledge the contribution of animals working in the armed services, such as dogs searching for explosives, and also reminds me of the countless thousands of horses that died in the First and Second World Wars.
My thoughts also turn to those who served in silence; it is sobering to remember that the ban on gay and lesbian soldiers serving in the UK armed forces was only lifted in January 2000. So many fought for freedoms they were not fully afforded themselves.
With all of this in mind, I find myself wondering, rather light-heartedly, how busy that particular Wetherspoons in the South of England is today. I am referring to the recent controversy where a local manager instructed door staff to deny entry to veterans and anyone wearing a poppy, labelling it a 'political' symbol. While I recognise it was an isolated incident and a PR disaster rather than company policy, it certainly served as a startling stimulus for a national debate on how the poppy is perceived by the country today.
It ties into other recent news items, where there has been much talk of a possible looming world conflict. The BBC reported on a survey of young people, many of whom said they would not take up arms for their country. I feel that the young - and perhaps those door staff - often mistake today’s Remembrance service for a glorification of war or a political statement, rather than a solemn remembering of the fallen and a giving of thanks for their sacrifice.
I imagine if Lewis were writing about today, he might focus on the quiet, unglamorous duty of remembering the fallen. He would strip away any political jingoism and focus entirely on the solemn, heart-breaking reality of a person laying down their life for another. To quote the closing line from today’s broadcast: “Remembrance day is every day.”
Why This Matters
Understanding the difference between revenge and protective duty allows us to honour those who fought to protect the innocent. By passing down these fragmented histories and articulating the grief of the unburied, we ensure that we do not mistake profound sacrifice for mere politics.
My Action for Today
Reader Question
How do you observe Remembrance Sunday, and do you have any ancestors whose old photographs remain a mystery to you?


No comments:
Post a Comment