The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: War as a harsh but necessary reminder of mortality, the shattering of earthly utopias, and defending the academic life as an approach to the Divine.• Source Material: Learning in War-Time (from The Weight of Glory)
My Reflection
Today’s passage presents me with immediate questions for Lewis. I am not a fan of the assertion that "great" Christians of the past would have seen war as a blessing. I am not arguing that they did not think this way, but aggression and violence simply seem at odds with the Christian message. Also, the idea that striving for world peace is a completely foolish endeavour - a misguided attempt to create heaven on earth - sits uneasily with me. I do not think a world without conflict is my idea of heaven anyway, but how can I even attempt to reason such concepts when they are so far beyond my human experience?
It also seems rather convenient that Lewis cites the occupation of a life of learning as an approved route to the Divine. I feel that many people who, for one reason or another, do not pursue academia are able to experience aspects of the Divine and its beauty in their own way, through their own ordinary occupations. I have never felt Lewis to be harsh, but today’s passage paints a picture of someone who is somewhat out of touch with other ways of living. I could be completely wrong, but a life filled with the continual contemplation of mortality sounds like a life filled with angst and dread.
War is a reminder of death, I agree. But so is losing one’s mother to cancer, one’s father to a heart attack, or the suicide of a friend. I know how deeply Lewis’s experience of the Somme and having to live through the Second World War affected him, which may explain his focus on war as the ultimate reminder of mortality. But death wears many faces, some of which are subtle and pernicious. One day a loved one is here, the next they are gone. Or, possibly even worse, we have to sit by the bed of a loved one as they slowly die in pain. Yes, war is a constant reminder, but so is life itself; from the moment of birth, it is nothing but entropy.
Why This Matters
Elevating academia as a special path to God excludes the profound spiritual wisdom found in ordinary life. Furthermore, framing war as the primary reminder of our mortality ignores the quiet, devastating grief of everyday loss that shapes so much of the human experience.
My Action for Today
Today, I will step away from academic theorising and find a quiet moment to honour the ordinary, non-academic lives that have deeply touched mine, remembering that the Divine is found just as easily in a hospital room as in a university hall.
Reader Question
Do you agree with Lewis that war dispels our "foolish hopes" for the world, or do you find his academic perspective out of touch with the reality of everyday grief?

No comments:
Post a Comment