The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: The "complex good" produced by human actions, the ethics of inflicting pain or death under authority, and the danger of volunteering for Satan's post.• Source Material: The Problem of Pain ("To Produce the Complex Good")
My Reflection
Today’s passage explores Lewis’s ideas on good and bad actions. He postulates that any action, whether good or bad, ultimately achieves God’s aims, though the manner will dictate its reward—whether we serve like John or like Judas. He states that "bad" actions, including the taking of a life, can be justified if the outcome is a good one. He provides excellent examples of where inflicting pain achieves a positive outcome, such as a surgeon undertaking an operation at the patient’s behest.
This makes complete logical sense. My profound reservation, however, lies in the semantics of what constitutes "good" and "bad" when placed in the hands of human authority. These concepts too easily conjure up the justifications for "Holy Wars." While some may only remember these in the context of the medieval Crusades, these wars exist today and are being fought on many fronts in the name of "supposed good." I am mercifully thankful that I have never had to take up arms or be forced into the trenches to witness the horror of warfare as Lewis did at the Somme. Yet it does not escape me that there are those in this world who encourage and perpetuate wars, not only for financial gain but as a tool to keep populations divided and in fear. Relinquishing our power and control to governments makes us pawns in their hands. Being fed a constant diet of propaganda that supports their aims of control leaves me deeply concerned for the future of humanity.
When Lewis speaks of the soldier's authority to kill for an obvious good, I think about my relative, William, who died at twenty-one in the Boer War. His body was never recovered and remains lost somewhere in the South African desert. What "supposed good" did his death achieve?
The modern rhetoric feels entirely Orwellian. Newspeak dictates that "War is Peace," "Ignorance is Strength," and "Freedom is Slavery"—all uncomfortably close to the World Economic Forum's 2016 assertion that "You'll own nothing and you'll be happy." How any of this is part of God’s plan for the world baffles me. I am happy to be in the autumn of my life, but I am simultaneously deeply, deeply worried for our younger people inheriting this system. Doing His work, as Lewis states, means accepting His wages. But volunteering for the post of Satan carries a different price, reminding me starkly of Romans 6:23: "The wages of sin is death."
Why This Matters
Theoretical justifications for violence and affliction often unravel when confronted with the reality of historical grief. True moral discernment requires looking past governmental propaganda to see the human cost of these so-called "complex goods."
My Action for Today
Today, I will hold space for the memory of William and all those who were swallowed by wars they did not start, choosing to cultivate peace in my own quiet corner of the world.
Reader Question
How do you reconcile the idea of God using evil actions to produce a "complex good" with the tragic, senseless realities of war?

No comments:
Post a Comment