The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: Lewis's personal experience of tribulation, ordinary pleasures treated as "broken toys," and tribulations ceasing only when remaking is achieved or deemed hopeless.• Source Material: The Problem of Pain ("One Man's Tale of Tribulation")
My Reflection
Today finds me in somewhat of my own tribulations after a sleepless night with excruciating leg and feet pain due to my diabetic neuropathy. Is this the agony Lewis famously describes as the ‘megaphone’?
Recently, I found myself in a position of simple happiness over some trivial delight, only for it to be snatched away not twenty-four hours later. In that respect, I can relate entirely to today’s passage where Lewis writes about enjoying the pleasures of life only to have them shattered by world events or failing physical health.
What I cannot accept, however, is the picture he paints that these painful interruptions are deliberate divine intrusions designed to force our attention back onto God. If I read Lewis correctly, he seems to advocate an existence where every waking moment must be spent in anxious contemplation of the Divine and begging for forgiveness. It strikes me as a profoundly masochistic life—wearing a perpetual hair-shirt and engaging in daily theological self-flagellation. How on earth did Lewis manage his daily tasks, his tutorials, or the ordinary round of life when, by his own logic, we ought to be on our knees pleading to be remade?
The final sentence made me reel: Lewis asserts that tribulations cannot cease until God sees us remade or “sees that our remaking is now hopeless.” I was always under the impression that God would never abandon the individual, yet here Lewis suggests the Divine might simply throw his hands up and declare someone a lost cause. Perhaps my mind is clouded by exhaustion and severe pain, rendering me unable to appreciate the "pearl of wisdom" Lewis is trying to offer.
Once again, I simply fail to meet this rigid spiritual checklist of approved behaviours. A throwaway comment from the Mere Apologetics DVD series noted that at one point in his spiritual journey, Lewis described himself as believing in God while not being a Christian.
With every passing day of this book, that definition feels increasingly apt for me.
Historical Footnote (1951)
1951: Prince Caspian (the second volume published in The Chronicles of Narnia) is published by Geoffrey Bles, London.
Why This Matters
When physical pain robs us of sleep, theological assertions that God deliberately breaks our earthly joys to keep us dependent sound like gaslighting. True faith cannot be sustained by viewing ordinary human contentment as dirty manure, nor by fearing that God will simply abandon us if our "remaking" proves too stubborn.
My Action for Today
Today, I will show myself absolute grace. Exhausted by neuropathy and lack of sleep, I refuse to judge my spiritual standing by Lewis's severe standards, choosing instead to find rest wherever my body and mind can take it.
Reader Question
Does viewing earthly joys as "broken toys" help you cope with suffering, or does it make everyday life feel needlessly grim?

No comments:
Post a Comment