The Reading Today
• Daily Theme: Childhood self-will, the controversial idea of "breaking" a child, and the daily "death" of the ego.• Source Material: The Problem of Pain ("The Rebellious Self")
My Reflection
Today’s passage discusses self-will and rebellion. I think I may have had a slightly different childhood to some, as I was, and to some extent still am, a rather passive person. I understand that children need some form of discipline and guidance, but the text makes it sound like you’re trying to break in a horse.
Lewis again uses language which I find to be coded or inaccessible, especially the word ‘death’. All this writing seems to me to frame a person as some terrible problem in need of correction and solutions forever. This endless cycle of begging for forgiveness; does it ever end? Are people really this bad?
My own experience of growing up was framed by cold and distant parents, who barely enquired as to anything relating to me. It was very much the Victorian concept of ‘children being seen but not heard.’ From what I see on social media these days, parents are trying to rewrite this narrative to place more emphasis on listening to the child, knowing more about their lives, and being actively involved in it. This doesn’t always work, but I think the attempt should be praised.
How any of this relates to us as adults, and Lewis’s assertion that we may have developed ‘more subtle forms’ of avoiding ‘death by various compensations’, is totally beyond me. What it does do, though, is make me feel that I am still in somewhat of a ‘rebellious’ state—though what I am rebelling against, I am unsure. As the famous line from the film The Wild One goes, when asked what he's rebelling against, Marlon Brando's character replies, ‘Whaddya got?’
For once, I’m with Johnny.
Historical Footnote (1942)
1942: A Preface to Paradise Lost is published by Oxford University Press. (A fitting footnote for today, given that Milton's epic is the ultimate story of cosmic rebellion!)
Why This Matters
Theological framing that treats human beings as inherently wicked problems to be "broken" can be deeply exhausting and emotionally damaging. It is essential to question archaic views on discipline and recognise the value of modern, empathetic approaches to human development.
My Action for Today
Today, I will step off the treadmill of feeling like a "problem" that needs to be solved or broken. I will allow myself to simply exist without needing to constantly beg for forgiveness for my own nature.
Reader Question
Do you think the old-fashioned concept of "breaking a child's will" did more harm than good to previous generations?

No comments:
Post a Comment