Tuesday, 6 October 2026

Day 76: The Magnifying Glass, The Witches of Eastwick, and the Source of Pain (6th October)


The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: Human-inflicted atrocities versus natural suffering, arbitrary theological fractions, and questioning God's enormous permission of torture.
• Source Material:  The Problem of Pain ("The Source of Pain")

My Reflection

Today’s passage tackles the concept of pain, both that inflicted by man and that which is unaccounted for. From an early age at school during History lessons, I was immediately struck by how much of the syllabus was taken up with accounts of conflict, not only in my own country but in the wider world. We had an illustrated modern history textbook, and some of its images remain with me to this day; in fact, when writing this post they immediately sprang to mind. The book contained pictures of soldiers in the trenches during World War One, an image of a little Vietnamese child running down a road screaming under the effects of napalm, another of the many bodies in the ‘Jonestown Massacre’, one of the assassination of John F. Kennedy and Lee Harvey Oswald, and lastly, a picture of a mushroom cloud.

From these lessons, I was immediately initiated into our modern world. At that early age, I genuinely believed that these atrocities were consigned to the past and that society was moving towards global peace. How wrong I was.

But this is only half of the story, as Lewis points out. (Although his fraction did strike me as curious—how exactly did he arrive at four-fifths?) Lewis asks why God permits such suffering in the world. On top of man-made horrors, there is the issue of one’s personal health and the fear of illness and disease. If this world is truly God’s creation, then why did He create such a thing as cancer? So much in life is a lottery, a game we never wanted to play with rewards we do not really want. One only has to watch the television during the day to see the enormous number of requests for aid from people starving, displaced due to wars, cruelty to children and animals... the list is endless.

In the film The Witches of Eastwick, there is a scene where the three women are asked what they think about human existence, to which one of them replies: “I don’t mind that it is a short life, I just don’t understand why there has to be so much pain.” It may be a frivolous film, but it asks an important question, one to which I still have no answer.

Sometimes I feel that we are like tiny ants at the mercy of a schoolboy’s magnifying glass in the sunshine. It elicits feelings of anger and rage not just against my fellow humans, but also towards the Creator. Like Mr. Emerson in Forster's A Room With A View, I scream, “Why, why, why?”, and unfortunately there is no answer, there is no reply, there is no comfort.

Why This Matters

Reconciling man-made horrors and natural diseases with a loving Creator is the ultimate stumbling block of faith. Refusing to accept tidy, mathematical theological answers—like arbitrary fractions—honours the true, devastating weight of human suffering.

My Action for Today

Today, I will not force myself to find a comforting answer where there isn't one. I will acknowledge the painful reality of the world and allow myself to feel the anger and the "Why?", without demanding an immediate theological rationale.

Reader Question

Do you find theological explanations of suffering helpful, or do they feel like empty words when you are faced with the actual pain of the world?

No comments:

Post a Comment