Saturday, 3 October 2026

Day 73: The Great Iconoclast, Chanel No. 5, and the Power of Photographs (3rd October)

 



The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: The danger of letting images (physical or mental) replace reality, and God as the ultimate breaker of our static ideas (the Iconoclast).
• Source Material:  A Grief Observed ("The Great Iconoclast")

My Reflection

Today’s passage prompted me to go straight to my OED to look up the definition of the word ‘iconoclast’; despite having an excellent education, this word obviously fell through the net. After reading the first few sentences, my face adopted its usual quizzical expression.

Photographs are a huge passion of mine. Having no living relatives, their photographic image is the only way I can combat my memory’s fading recollection of them. When I look at a photograph of a departed loved one, it brings back their voice, their laugh, and even their smell—in the case of Nanny (my maternal grandmother), it is Ellenette hairspray and Chanel No. 5. My photographs are some of my most treasured possessions, of which I have hundreds thanks to Poppa (my maternal grandfather) and my father both being avid photographers during their lifetimes.

So why is Lewis describing them as a ‘poor’ substitute for the original? I have no delusion that somehow the photograph ‘is’ the person; it is simply, for me, a bridge to them, a way of connecting. I doubt I am alone in this idea.

I have always found the communion wafer an odd ecclesiastical object. While communion in and of itself is a profound act of worship, I am always struck by the feeling that I am some poor schoolboy who, after having apologised for his wrong-doings, is continually brought to the Headmaster’s office to apologise repeatedly over and over again after previously being told that he had been forgiven.

In defence of ‘icons’ in their original sense, I find them of great comfort. I have Catholic friends whose house is replete with pictures of the Virgin Mother and Her Child. When I admire them, firstly I see the great work of art that they are, and then I am connected to the Divine through what they represent. You cannot have it both ways, Jack; you cannot say that religious imagery is a second-rate experience and then ask me to go to church and see the very same thing filling its space.

Once again, we are being told that this is wrong and this is right. When reading Lewis I often feel rather uneducated and think I must improve myself, but I feel that sometimes knowing less makes decisions easier somehow. The more you know, the harder it is to obtain the answer you are seeking. I have no idea what Lewis means when he writes, “All reality is iconoclastic,” having only truly learnt its definition today. Perhaps I will jump out of the theological ‘bath’ sometime soon, but for now, I will have to wallow in the warm and soapy water of my ignorance.

Do I get rid of my ‘beautiful’ marble head of Christ? Do I throw away the ornate wooden crucifix upon my mantlepiece? Something about ‘graven idols’ springs to mind. Today’s report card most likely will say, “Must try harder”.

Why This Matters

We often rely on physical objects, photographs, and art as vital bridges to the people and the Divine that we love. Reconciling our deep human need for these sensory connections with theology's demand for unvarnished reality is a messy, deeply personal process.

My Action for Today

Today, I will not throw away my marble head of Christ or my crucifix. I will appreciate my photographs and religious items for exactly what they are—beautiful, necessary bridges that help my fading human memory connect with the reality of those I love.

Reader Question

Do you have a specific photograph or physical object that instantly brings back the voice or scent of a loved one?

No comments:

Post a Comment