Wednesday, 30 September 2026

Day 70: Bromidic Comforts, Hieronymus Bosch, and the Terrifying 'At Peace' (30th September)

 



The Reading Today

• Daily Theme: The terrifying uncertainty of life after death, the inadequacy of well-meaning platitudes, and the brutal reality of the problem of pain.
• Source Material:  A Grief Observed ("At Peace")

My Reflection

Today’s passage raises a truly terrifying idea: does suffering actually end with our death?

Lewis describes the words of ‘comfort’ offered by people after the passing of his wife, Joy. He outlines her own final words, stating her peace with the Creator, and notes that she was a shrewd woman, not easily fooled or deceived. The platitudes of others—in the typical vein of ‘being at peace’ and ‘in God’s hands’—are all too typical of those wishing to offer sympathy to those experiencing the loss of a loved one. In their defence, people desperately want to help, but they often lack the appropriate vocabulary for grief, falling back instead on these bromidic comforts.

Lewis highlights, although vaguely, that many people of faith do not necessarily believe that our suffering ends with our death. In fact, it may be the beginning of an eternity of it. In my mind, this is not exactly the best selling point for belief in an afterlife.

Lewis postulates that if, as people state, the departed person is now "in God’s hands," were they not in His hands all the time, throughout their life? His argument regarding God’s inconsistency is chilling: if God is 'good', yet hurts us throughout our lives, surely the terrifying possibility exists that this hurt would continue after death.

I am struck today by an argument from the actor Stephen Fry. Whilst I am not what one would call a ‘fan’ of his, I agree he is a consummate orator, and his arguments are always well-constructed even if one disagrees. He was once interviewed on his thoughts about faith and the Creator, and he made an argument which has rented a room in my head ever since. His question was simply: “What is bone cancer in children all about?” He railed that when he reached the Pearly Gates, he would argue with God that the suffering inflicted on the innocent seems to be the actions of a capricious and vengeful entity.

Whilst these concepts may be deeply uncomfortable to Christians, they are entirely deserving of examination. As a child at school during Religious Instruction class, I was filled with concepts and imagery worthy of a Hieronymus Bosch painting. The idea of burning in Hell; the destiny awaiting the wicked; those who are not deserving of His love and protection. These spiritual conflicts still plague me from time to time, and they certainly do not align with my idea of being at ‘Peace’.


Why This Matters

When dealing with the raw reality of grief, well-meaning platitudes often do more harm than good. A mature faith requires us to look unflinchingly at the terrifying, uncomfortable questions about suffering, rather than hiding behind bromidic comforts and childhood nightmares.

My Action for Today

Today, I will not force myself to accept easy answers or tidy theological bows. I will allow myself to sit with the uncomfortable, terrifying questions of faith, acknowledging that doubt and anger are natural, honest responses to the human experience of pain.

Reader Question

Have you ever found well-meaning platitudes like "they are at peace" to be more distressing than comforting when dealing with the loss of a loved one?

No comments:

Post a Comment